Baroness Cass Expresses Concerns Over Draft Bill Banning Conversion Practices
According to a report from BBC UK, Baroness Cass stated she does not support the current draft bill banning conversion practices, citing potential serious unintended consequences for parents and medical professionals, despite having previously supported the concept.
The author of the independent review concerning gender identity services for young people indicated to BBC UK that she does not endorse the present draft bill intended to ban conversion practices, even though she had previously welcomed the idea.
Speaking before a parliamentary committee examining the bill, which the government stated aims to safeguard LGBT individuals in England and Wales, Baroness Cass expressed that the current phrasing of the legislation carries the risk of causing "serious unintended consequences" for parents of children experiencing gender distress or for medical professionals operating in that field.
Baroness Cass voiced apprehension regarding the potential for "vexatious" complaints under the bill's existing wording, suggesting it could lead to the prosecution of families and therapists who work with young people experiencing gender distress.
When the government released its draft legislation earlier this year, Baroness Cass had been quoted in the publicity materials, stating that she was pleased the government was introducing legislation that provided a clearer definition of conversion practices and also specified what they were not. She had also expressed anticipation for the bill undergoing further review before it became law. However, when questioned at the Draft Conversion Practices Bill committee about her support for the bill's present form, she responded with a simple "no."
Baroness Cass noted that the heightened "polarisation" within the debate surrounding gender might result in the new law being utilized in ways that were not intended. The current wording of the bill requires that the victim must have suffered "serious harm to the individual's physical or mental health, or serious alarm or distress to the individual which has a substantial adverse effect on their usual day-to-day activities."
Baroness Cass stated that she was worried this specific wording allowed for the possibility of "vexatious" complaints, which could place therapists who work with young people experiencing gender distress at risk of being prosecuted. She elaborated that if a young person had experienced sexual abuse, any discussion of it would likely be very triggering, and she argued that if a therapist could not therapeutically address the issue without referencing it, that presented a problem.
Professionals working at the new NHS Gender Dysphoria Clinics expressed concerns that even complaints processes that did not result in a prosecution could still be damaging.
Furthermore, Baroness Cass raised concerns about the potential effect the new law might have on families. For example, she mentioned that if a parent withheld a child's money because they believed the child might purchase a "breast binder or hormones," this action could potentially fall under the bill's scope and lead to prosecution.
Regarding her prior support for the bill's initial publication, Baroness Cass explained that she favored the concept but had not had the opportunity to read the specifics before the press release was issued, yet she had provided the quote regardless. She previously described conversion practices as "abhorrent" when publishing her report on gender identity services for young people in 2024, and she maintained that no LGBT people should be subjected to conversion practices. She communicated to the committee that she desired "a bill that protects the people it's supposed to protect, but doesn't accidentally entrap those who you don't want to [entrap]."
A government spokesperson commented that they welcome Baroness Cass's support for taking action to end abusive conversion practices, alongside her comments regarding the necessity of legislation to prevent adverse outcomes. The spokesperson added that they would treat all evidence presented to the committee seriously as they proceed with efforts to conclude nearly a decade of delay for LGBT+ people who should not have to endure abuse in an attempt to change their identity. The committee hearings are ongoing.