Concerns Raised Over Magistrate's Decision to Remand Mr. Azruddin Mohamed in Custody
A letter published in Kaieteur News argues that the Magistrate erred by remanding Mr. Azruddin Mohamed without first exploring reasonable bail conditions to mitigate risks of further offending or witness interference.
According to a letter published in Kaieteur News on November 20, 2026, the author referenced Mr. Azruddin Mohamed's failed bail application before Magistrate Abigail Gibbs on October 30, 2026, and the subsequent dismissal of a Judicial Review application on November 16, 2026.
The grounds for the Judicial Review cited were that the Magistrate made an error by placing Mr. Azruddin Mohamed in custody without first assessing whether reasonable conditions could address the identified risks, which include further offending and interference with witnesses, specifically mentioning SI Narine.
The letter asserts that it constitutes an error of law and principle to deny bail and remand an accused person in custody without conducting the constitutionally required assessment of whether the legitimate goals of detention—namely, preventing further offending and witness interference—could be better achieved through appropriately tailored bail conditions.
Furthermore, the author stated that the Magistrate's obligation is to uphold the accused person's right to personal liberty and their presumption of innocence, as stipulated under Article 139(4) and Article 144(2)(a) of the Constitution, respectively.
While there are recognized exceptions where there are valid reasons to believe a person might fail to surrender, commit more offenses, interfere with witnesses, or obstruct justice, the letter contended that Article 139(4) is a mandatory provision requiring a two-part assessment to be completed before any remand in custody.
This assessment requires first determining if the accused can be held on unconditional bail. If not, based on a recognized ground for refusal, the second step is to determine if the risks associated with that ground (such as the risk of further offending or witness interference) can be managed through reasonable conditions.
The letter claimed that it is an error of law for a Magistrate to fail to consider clear conditions like house arrest, electric monitoring, or a curfew, as these measures can protect the accused's liberty while reducing the risk of further offenses and witness interference, thereby balancing personal freedom against recognized risks.
The author noted that the Magistrate's High Court affidavit did not adequately demonstrate compliance with the mandatory provision of Article 139(4), suggesting fresh grounds for a renewed Judicial Review application, although the letter mentioned that counsel's path to bail might be simpler on Appeal to the High Court, referencing a judgment by Judge Chandra-Hanif.
Despite the potential for an appeal, the letter emphasized the public importance of the Judicial Review to ensure that the right to liberty in Guyana is actively protected, allowing the High Court a second chance to confirm the mandate to release an innocent person either conditionally or unconditionally.
The letter further argued that Magistrates must clearly state the reasons why certain conditions are inadequate to lessen any posed risks. It also pointed out that bail conditions should follow an escalating scale of restriction; if reporting to the police station, a condition set during extradition hearings, is not enough to stop further offending based on the accused's conduct, a more severe condition should be considered before resorting to custody.
Finally, the author submitted that the presumption of innocence must be actively practiced rather than merely stated.