Ed Miliband States He Will Not Resign Over Rosebank Oil Field Despite Past Opposition
Ed Miliband stated he would not resign if the government approves the Rosebank oil field, despite previously criticizing the scheme as "climate vandalism." A decision regarding the field off Shetland will be made by Miatta Fahnbulleh, who took over as energy secretary from Miliband in July.
According to the BBC UK, Ed Miliband indicated that he would "definitely not" resign should the government grant approval for the Rosebank oil field, even though he had previously characterized the project as "climate vandalism." Miliband stated that he would adhere to collective responsibility as a member of the government. He clarified that Miatta Fahnbulleh, who succeeded Miliband as energy secretary in July, will be the one to make the determination on the future of the oil field located off Shetland. Miliband also mentioned that he would not second-guess Fahnbulleh's decision on Rosebank.
Some Labour Members of Parliament oppose the project, while the Conservative party maintains that there is a necessity to "get Britain drilling." Miliband had previously voiced his concerns regarding Rosebank while the Labour party was in opposition. During an appearance on BBC Radio 4's Today programme, Miliband was reminded that in 2023, he had described the project as "climate vandalism and a colossal waste of taxpayer money." When asked if he would resign if his successor decided to develop Rosebank, Miliband responded that he would not, citing his adherence to collective responsibility. He added that he supported the energy secretary's recent authorization of the Jackdaw gas field following years of uncertainty and a court case.
Catherine Fookes is mentioned as being part of a group of at least 75 Labour MPs who have signed a letter opposing Rosebank. The MP for Monmouthshire told Today that they needed to examine their actions to prevent worsening climate challenges, adding that drilling in the North Sea would achieve exactly that.
Conversely, Steve Yemm, the Labour MP for Mansfield, expressed his backing for Rosebank, suggesting it would serve as a measure to test whether the country could support investment and skilled employment in the North Sea while still meeting its climate commitments. One Labour MP who supports Rosebank indicated growing confidence that the decision would favor development, though they noted that the situation would change after Fookes's involvement. This MP also accused Miliband of managing two departments and suggested the current energy ministers were all affiliated with him.
Rosebank, which is Britain's largest untapped oil field and would also yield gas, is situated approximately 80 miles (128km) north-west of Shetland. The then-Conservative UK government granted a license for Rosebank in 2023, which subsequently led to a legal challenge. The Court of Session in Edinburgh ruled last year that the government's approval was unlawful, placing the current Labour government in the position of making a new determination on whether to proceed. If approved, Rosebank is projected to yield up to 500m barrels of oil over its 25-year operational lifespan.
Environmental activists contend that approving Rosebank would impede climate change mitigation efforts and would not significantly affect the UK's energy security or utility costs. They have further argued that Rosebank would pose a greater environmental risk than Jackdaw because it would generate substantially more greenhouse gases that contribute to global warming. The UK has committed to achieving net zero by 2050, which involves reducing carbon emissions until they are balanced by removals, and it aims to limit global warming to no more than 1.5C above pre-industrial levels.
Conservative shadow energy secretary Andrew Bowie stated that a single gas field does not constitute an energy strategy. Bowie also asserted that the Labour party could not claim to support the North Sea while simultaneously blocking new licenses, undermining investor confidence, and imposing a substantial windfall tax on the industry. Bowie concluded that it was evident that Labour could not be relied upon to deliver the necessary energy security, noting that some of the party's MPs appeared ready to dissent regarding the approval of Rosebank.