assembled.
Guyana

Guyana Times Article Clarifies Limits of Free Speech Under Constitution

A piece published in the Guyana Times discusses the scope of freedom of speech in Guyana, asserting that while the Constitution protects expression on various topics, it does not shield hate speech or libel, and citizens should use the court system for reporting wrongdoing.

An editorial illustration showing a stone tablet and an open book in a grand, empty space, with a beam of light being contained by a jagged barrier, symbolizing constitutional limits on free speech.
AI-generated illustration

According to the Guyana Times, a significant discussion is occurring regarding freedom of speech in Guyana, particularly in response to criticism directed at the President for employing an attorney to address scandalous remarks made by Facebook users concerning him and his government, including remarks about his mother. The author of the piece disagrees with the notion that such actions constitute an attack on free speech, stating that the Constitution provides clear guidelines on the matter.

Article 146(1) of the Constitution of Guyana is cited as providing a strong protection for freedom of expression, which encompasses the right to hold opinions without interference, to receive ideas and information without interference, and to communicate ideas and information without interference. This means every Guyanese possesses the right to criticize the government, disagree with its policies, and express these views publicly.

However, the same article includes limitations. Article 146(2)(b) stipulates that nothing done under the authority of any law contravenes the right to expression to the extent that the law provides for protection of the reputations, rights, and freedoms of other persons. Furthermore, Article 40(2) specifies that fundamental rights and freedoms are subject to limitations intended to prevent any individual's enjoyment of those rights from negatively affecting the rights and freedoms of others or the public interest. Article 146(3) explicitly states that freedom of expression does not cover hate speech or other forms of expression that might incite hostility or ill-will toward any person or group of people.

Consequently, the article asserts that freedom of speech does not grant permission to scandalize or libel individuals. Making scandalous comments about any person on Facebook is characterized as a misuse of freedom of speech, using a constitutional right as a pretext for actions the Constitution itself does not safeguard.

The Constitution does protect the right to speak on national development, government policies, the economy, social issues, and other related subjects. Article 13 establishes that the primary goal of the political system is to establish an inclusionary democracy by increasing opportunities for citizen participation, meaning criticism, debate, and dissent are integral to this.

Nevertheless, a distinction is drawn between criticizing a policy and attacking a person's character without evidence. If a citizen possesses evidence of misconduct, such as corruption or abuse of office, the proper avenue for addressing this is the court system. Article 144(8) guarantees that any court established for determining a civil right or obligation must be independent and impartial, and that the case must receive a fair hearing within a reasonable timeframe. Additionally, Article 149D(1) assures that the State will not deny any person equality before the law or equal protection and benefit of the law.

Therefore, the suggested procedure is to take evidence and file it as a civil matter for the courts to decide, adhering to the rule of law. The author contends that individuals should not act as judge and jury on Facebook by making unproven allegations, and then claim protection under freedom of speech when held accountable.

The President, like any other citizen, has the right to protect his reputation and his family's reputation. The act of retaining an attorney to pursue libel is presented not as an attack on free speech, but as the utilization of the same legal system available to all Guyanese. If the President is subject to the law, then those who libel him must also be subject to the law, which is what equality before the law entails.

The piece concludes by suggesting a need for a more mature discussion on the subject, emphasizing that while freedom of speech is a vital right that must be defended, defending it also requires preventing its abuse, as using it as a cover for scandal and libel weakens the right for everyone else.

Keep reading

More Guyana