Guyana Times Criticizes Kendesi Mohammed's Critique of Attorney General Nandlall
The Guyana Times published a piece arguing that Kendesi Mohammed's recent critique of Attorney General Mohabir Anil Nandlall, SC, MP, was factually flawed and poorly constructed. The article detailed the Attorney General's legal background and actions, including his role in constitutional matters and legislative reforms.
According to the Guyana Times, Kendesi Mohammed's recent commentary directed at Attorney General Mohabir Anil Nandlall, SC, MP, was deemed factually unsound and compositionally weak. The publication asserted that it was intellectually improper to compare Mr. Nandlall, described as a battle-tested jurist and a three-term Attorney General who has represented Guyana before the International Court of Justice, with ordinary political commentators. Mr. Nandlall has reportedly litigated significant constitutional issues before the Caribbean Court of Justice for over two decades and has received formal judicial praise for his persuasive advocacy.
The Guyana Times noted that Mr. Mohammed's diatribe suffered from factual inaccuracies and structural incoherence. Specifically, the publication pointed out a self-contradiction in Mr. Mohammed's writing, where he criticized Mr. Nandlall for defending the Government's position, despite earlier defining the Attorney General's primary duty as representing the state in litigation. The article also mentioned that Mr. Mohammed made unsubstantiated claims regarding petroleum contracts, which the Times characterized as hollow truisms.
Regarding the legal assertions made by Kendesi Mohammed, the Guyana Times stated that his claims disintegrated under scrutiny. First, concerning the extradition proceedings against Azruddin Mohamed, Mr. Mohammed alleged that the Attorney General was wasting public funds by pursuing the matter domestically instead of involving American attorneys. The Times countered that this assertion demonstrated a lack of understanding of sovereign jurisdiction, as foreign prosecutors lack standing to appear in Guyanese courts, and the state is legally bound by bilateral treaties and Guyana’s Fugitive Offenders Act to handle extradition requests internally. Furthermore, the publication noted that because Mr. Mohamed initiated constitutional litigation against the State of Guyana, Article 112 of the Constitution requires the Attorney General to defend the nation.
Concerning challenges to the 2016 Stabroek Block Production Sharing Agreement and demands for stricter terms in future agreements, the Guyana Times stated that Mr. Mohammed ignored Article 32 of the contract, which prevents unilateral changes and could expose Guyana to substantial international arbitration awards if violated. The article further pointed out that the Administration had already enacted the Petroleum Activities Act 2023 and a revised Model Production Sharing Agreement, which impose higher corporate taxes, royalties, and strict ring-fencing on all subsequent oil blocks.
Finally, when Mr. Mohammed questioned the progress of constitutional and legislative modernization, the Guyana Times stated that Mr. Nandlall had initiated the Constitution Reform Commission Act, and the twenty-member Constitutional Reform Commission is currently carrying out its mandate while gathering public input before its deadline of December 31, 2026. Additionally, Mr. Nandlall has led the modernization of statutes, including the Data Protection Act, the Arbitration Act, and the Bail Act.