Northern Ireland Pectus Excavatum Waits for Surgery Amid Concerns Over Early Treatment Access
Charlie Clarke, who experienced significant self-consciousness due to pectus excavatum as a teenager, is one of 85 individuals in Northern Ireland awaiting surgery. The Department of Health acknowledged lengthy waits, while a local consultant noted the lack of non-surgical options in the region.
According to BBC UK, Charlie Clarke, who is 26 years old and from County Down, experienced intense self-consciousness during her teenage years because of a physical deformity. She mentioned that having pectus excavatum, which is described as a disability and a deformity under her shirt, was at times difficult. Her most distressing memories involved hiding in the school bathroom during physical education to prevent other girls from commenting on her chest. Clarke stated that she felt awful in her school uniform because of her appearance and the comments she received about her chest.
Pectus excavatum, a congenital chest wall condition, affects one in every 200 people. This condition can compress the heart and lungs, leading to increased heart rate and breathlessness, which may cause loss of consciousness. Charlie is currently one of 85 people in Northern Ireland awaiting surgery for pectus conditions. While many on the waiting list have been waiting for less than two years, five individuals have been on the list for over five years.
The Department of Health has acknowledged that some patients in Northern Ireland have experienced extended waits for surgery. The Department stated that the combination of the patient volume and other demands on the thoracic surgery service has contributed to pressures on waiting times. However, the Department also indicated that it has secured additional funding for more surgeries to decrease the number of people on the waiting list, resulting in extra pectus procedures over the last three years, and has agreed to a further proposal intended to reduce both the number of waiting patients and the duration of their waits.
Clarke shared that she was previously misdiagnosed, including being told she had anxiety. She explained that she was only referred to a thoracic surgeon at age 23 after a clinical technician observed that her heart could not be seen on a scan because it was compressed. This age is considered too old for non-surgical treatment.
Niall McGonigle, a consultant thoracic surgeon based in Northern Ireland, specializes in chest wall deformities. McGonigle shared that he himself suffered from a pectus deformity as a child and underwent surgery at age 17. He noted that the condition was not recognized in Northern Ireland, and patients are sometimes dismissed as seeking cosmetic surgery, which is not the case, as there is evidence of restrictions on the lungs and heart that can be debilitating. McGonigle stated that while early diagnosis allows for treatment with non-surgical services, Northern Ireland does not provide this service, forcing young people to seek care in England.
Clarke's planned surgery will involve placing two metal bars in her chest and a metal plate in her sternum to allow her heart and lungs to return to their natural positions. She expressed her desire to speak out to raise awareness of the condition and to assist others who have it, including her 11-year-old sister, so that she does not have to wait as long and risk her condition becoming life-threatening.
Pectus excavatum, also known as "funnel chest," varies among individuals and is often present from birth. It involves the breastbone curving inward, causing the chest to appear sunken or hollow, and is typically more noticeable during childhood or adolescence. Treatments include vacuum bell therapy, which uses a suction device over the sunken chest to gradually lift the breastbone forward, and compression bracing, which is most effective in teenagers but generally less so once the chest becomes rigid in adulthood.
The Department of Health mentioned that work conducted in 2023 led to the commissioning of a service for "non-surgical bracing of pectus carinatum," which is understood to potentially negate the need for surgery in appropriately selected patients. The Department added that the impact of this service will be evaluated, including its potential to free up operating room capacity for conditions requiring surgical resolution. Simon Kendall, representing the charity Pectus Matters, commented that early treatment can save the health service money in the long run by avoiding major operations when the patient is young and the chest wall is more flexible.