assembled.
Business

Over 28,000 Tonnes of Waste at Dorset Quarry as Landowner Claims EA Inaction

A quarry near Corfe Mullen in Dorset has accumulated over 28,000 tonnes of waste, with the landowner asserting that the Environment Agency (EA) failed to act promptly despite repeated permit violations. Building minerals supplier MB Wilkes faces an estimated £3m cleanup bill, while the EA's chief executive acknowledged issues with permit suspension and revocation.

AI illustration based on reference photographs; not an event photograph. A large, uneven expanse of accumulated waste material forms irregular mounds in an open quarry setting under a clear sky.
AI-generated illustration

According to a report from the BBC UK, more than 28,000 tonnes of waste has been left at a quarry, with the landowner alleging that the Environment Agency (EA) did not respond quickly enough to repeated permit breaches. News of this waste dump comes a year after a huge rubbish mountain was reported in Kidlington, Oxfordshire, that later cost £6m to clear. Building minerals supplier MB Wilkes stated that the site near Corfe Mullen in Dorset now faces an estimated £3m cost to clear the area.

MB Wilkes indicated that concerns were raised a year after leasing the land to waste operator Hillier Recycling, but the accumulation of rubbish continued for six additional years before the EA revoked its permits. In September, three men pleaded guilty to offenses related to the site, and the EA stated it would not comment on the allegations from MB Wilkes until after a sentencing hearing scheduled for later this month.

The EA's chief executive, Philip Duffy, addressed permit concerns during a recent Environment and Climate Change Committee hearing, noting that permits were suspended or revoked too infrequently despite ongoing breaches, and that this situation needed to change.

Hillier Recycling entered liquidation in 2024 after abandoning an estimated 28,500 tonnes of rubbish at the location. Paul Wilkes, director of MB Wilkes, expressed his astonishment regarding the situation, telling the BBC, "Don't know what to say really. It's mind blowing," and adding, "The Environment Agency let it happen."

MB Wilkes had leased the land to Hillier Recycling for 10 years, beginning in 2015. Hillier Recycling had obtained two permits from the EA to manage inert waste, such as soil and rubble, as well as mixed commercial and industrial waste at the site. However, within a year, the landowner voiced worries regarding the site's operation and the types of waste being managed. Wilkes stated that when they requested the EA to stop the tipping, they were told they had it under control, but the lorries continued to arrive.

To prevent further waste from arriving, MB Wilkes employees attempted to block the site entrance with a lorry, but the company was instructed to remove the vehicle as it violated the lease conditions granted to Hillier Recycling.

Following Hillier Recycling's abandonment of the site and the expiration of the 10-year lease, the EA issued a Section 59 notice to the landowner, WB Wilkes, requiring the removal of the waste within a specified timeframe, even though the landowner did not handle the waste. The UK operates under the polluter pays principle, but if a waste operator ceases operations, the cleanup costs can fall on the landowner.

Consultants representing MB Wilkes suggested that questions should be raised regarding the EA's actions when concerns were raised and the issuance of the waste handling licenses. Rebecca Bomers, managing director of Somerton Environmental, stated that in her view, the two permits issued by the EA should never have been granted. Bomers further noted that the site was supposed to have a building to contain all waste permitted under the commercial waste permit, and that all site surfaces should have been impermeable, neither of which conditions had been met.

Records gathered by Bomers indicated that the EA conducted over 20 visits to the site between 2015 and 2022, repeatedly instructing Hillier Recycling to address numerous breaches of the permit terms. Due to the accumulation of persistent breaches, the site was classified as Compliance Band E, which is the second lowest rating, yet Hillier Recycling was permitted to continue handling waste. In one email exchange, the EA advised the operator to bring more waste to the site when another one of its operations exceeded capacity.

Vikki Slade, the Liberal Democrat MP for Mid Dorset North Poole, expressed concern over the site details, stating that it was unbelievable that extra waste was permitted to be dumped on a site already reported for permit breaches. She commented that the EA was repeatedly acting too slowly and not utilizing its powers sufficiently, noting that such situations damage the public's trust in authorities.

In November 2021, the EA suspended the acceptance of all waste at the site due to repeated failures. However, just four days later, the terms of this suspension were modified, and inert waste resumed arriving at the site as permit breaches persisted. The landowner claimed that other types of waste also continued to be brought to the site. On September 28, 2022, the EA halted all waste from entering the site. MB Wilkes asserted that the EA's failure to enforce compliance resulted in thousands of additional tonnes of waste piling up, and it was evident from the rubbish that household waste, which was not permitted, had also been dumped.

During the Environment and Climate Change Committee hearing, EA chief executive Philip Duffy commented on the peculiarity of the agency issuing permits to regulate various activities while rarely revoking or suspending them, which could allow for year-after-year permit breaches without significant consequences. Duffy stated that the EA intended to change this, adding that allowing operators in bands D, E, and F, where severe non-compliance concerns existed year after year, was unacceptable. He clarified that while operators in those bands would have a chance to improve, failure to do so would lead to suspension, and continued failure would result in permit revocation.

Anna Willetts, a partner at law firm gunnercooke, advised that the situation placed the landowner in a difficult position, as large quantities of waste were deposited on his land under EA permission by others, and his requests for help to stop the dumping were not acted upon, leaving him with a notice to clear it up, which could constitute a criminal offense if not complied with.

Keep reading

More Business