Work and Pensions Secretary Backs Legal Guarantee for Youth Employment Support
The work and pensions secretary supported the concept of legally guaranteeing young people assistance with employment, while a Conservative counterpart argued ministers should instead focus on lowering employer taxes. A review by Alan Milburn is expected to recommend job placements for under-25s and changes to universal credit.
According to BBC UK, the work and pensions secretary has endorsed the notion that the government should legally guarantee young people assistance in securing employment. Pat McFadden informed the BBC that job support requires a "legislative underpinning," noting that the current level of assistance is "vague."
McFadden also confirmed that some current benefit recipients would experience a reduction in their benefit entitlement upon reassessment. However, his Conservative counterpart, Helen Whately, stated that the concept of legally guaranteeing support "doesn't make sense," suggesting that ministers should instead concentrate on decreasing taxes levied on employers.
This discussion occurs ahead of a forthcoming review by former Labour cabinet minister Alan Milburn, which is anticipated to recommend that individuals under the age of 25 should be guaranteed job placements or training to aid in finding permanent employment. Milburn's report is also expected to suggest that under-25s should no longer be eligible for the health component of universal credit or personal independence payment (Pip), which is the primary disability benefit in England and Wales.
Under the proposed plans, some individuals might qualify for a new "additional cost allowance" to cover daily expenses linked to health conditions. Speaking to Sunday with Laura Kuenssberg, Milburn asserted that the government ought to redirect funds from the benefits system to enhance work support, adding that he desired to see "billions" in extra spending on assistance over the next ten years.
Milburn mentioned that the idea of lowering the entitlement for existing benefit recipients could generate controversy among Labour MPs, who previously blocked a benefits-cutting plan proposed under Sir Keir Starmer last year. He stated that any reduction in entitlement for some should be paired with a new "duty on government" to provide job support for young people, such as apprenticeships, college placements, job coaching, or a job.
Milburn commented that previous job support initiatives, including the Kickstart programme during the Covid pandemic, were less effective at reducing long-term joblessness due to their temporary nature. The practical implementation of the new guarantee remains unclear, with McFadden adding that it would need to be "carefully" drafted.
McFadden noted that while local councils possess certain specific legal responsibilities, such as in child protection and homelessness, the duties placed on central government are generally more extensive, exemplified by the operation of a "comprehensive" health service.
When asked on the same programme whether he agreed with the guarantee idea, McFadden responded that he believed some legislative foundation was necessary. He further stated that the support offered "needs to be more firm," adding that people require greater certainty regarding what they are entitled to. He confirmed that the government intends to transition younger claimants to a new benefits system during scheduled reassessments, and some of them would not receive the same amount they receive currently. Conversely, he added that other claimants, such as those with long-term disabilities, would receive an increased amount.
In another discussion with Kuenssberg, shadow work and pensions secretary Helen Whately stated that her party supports measures to decrease welfare spending. However, she criticized the proposed legal guarantee of work support, arguing that while it might "sound a nice thing to do," ministers would be better served by reducing taxes and regulations for businesses to help young people find "real jobs."
She asserted that it was "absurd" that the government had increased taxes for employers to "subsidise things that look like jobs," and advised, "Just stop doing the taxing."
In another segment of his interview, former health secretary Milburn remarked that a sustainable decrease in welfare spending cannot be achieved within two or three years, caution that "crude cuts" to the benefits system could generate other additional costs for the government. He also stated that GPs should not be responsible for issuing sick notes declaring individuals unable to work, and advised ministers to "look very carefully" at Labour's manifesto commitment to phase out the reduced minimum wage for those aged 18-21, noting that moves toward this had "imposed a lot of cost" on companies.
This commentary comes as the government announced it will expand the eligibility for its scheme that provides subsidized six-month job roles at the minimum wage for jobless under-25s. Starting next April, eligible claimants will be offered a role after 12 months of unsuccessful job searching, an increase from the current 18 months. This marks the second expansion of eligibility for the scheme, following an earlier increase in the maximum age from 21 to 24 this year.