assembled.
Guyana

Criticism of MV Barima Tragedy Response: Calls for Government Accountability Over Waterways

A letter published in Kaieteur News criticizes the testimony in the CoI regarding the MV Barima tragedy, asserting that maintenance status is no excuse for not requiring re-inspection before sailing. The writer demands that government officials be held accountable for management failures and insists that citizen safety must be the top priority.

A large, weathered cargo vessel rests on calm water under an overcast sky, emphasizing a sense of scrutiny.
AI-generated illustration

According to a letter published in Kaieteur News on November 14, 2026, the assertion presented during the Commission of Inquiry (CoI) concerning the MV Barima tragedy—that the vessel was undergoing maintenance and consequently, discovered safety issues were not escalated—is deemed insufficient. The author contends that this explanation does not excuse the failure to place the MV Barima on a list for escalation, reinspection, and official clearance before it was permitted to sail again.

The writer posits that the nation's waterways function similarly to roadways, and the government possesses the authority to dictate who may use them, the required condition of their vessels, and the necessary licenses or authorizations for use. The letter further states that there is no justifiable reason for a responsible government minister, ministry, or associated officials to cede complete control of the waterways to any vessel owner. Even the coast guard is required to adhere to the necessary standards for using the country's waterways.

It was noted that members of parliament have recently been detained for improperly using their vessels on the waterways, and the author argues that if individuals in high societal standing are not permitted to violate vessel laws on the rivers, then no other person should be allowed to do so. The letter asserts that if a vessel fails an inspection, it should remain grounded until necessary corrections are verified. The author referenced Suriname's recent actions and noted that ignoring safety concerns during inspections can result in the death of innocent children, citing the recent Mahdia school dorm tragedy as an example.

This situation is described as a recurrence of significant neglect of responsibility that has led to an even more severe tragedy. The author declared this situation entirely unacceptable and called for the officials involved, including the responsible Minister, to be held accountable for the poor management and resulting dereliction of duty. The letter concluded by emphasizing that the safety of citizens must be prioritized above all other considerations.

Keep reading

More Guyana