Generative AI's Performance in Finding Black Friday Deals Shows Mixed Results
A BBC UK investigation into generative AI tools like ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, and Alexa for finding Black Friday deals yielded inconsistent results, with some issues including broken links and inaccurate pricing, while a YouGov survey indicated the UK ranks low in AI usage for shopping.
The BBC UK reported on the performance of generative AI products, such as ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, in assisting with Black Friday deals, noting that while these tools have been promoted for this purpose, the actual results were varied during a test conducted a week before the major sales event.
A recent YouGov survey covering 19 nations indicated that the UK was positioned second-last regarding the proportion of individuals who reported using AI to aid their shopping. Furthermore, 36% of those surveyed who planned to shop during Black Friday stated they had no intention of utilizing an AI tool.
Tech companies have introduced features to capitalize on growing interest in AI for shopping; for instance, Amazon launched Alexa for Shopping for UK users in November, and OpenAI released a Shopping Research tool on ChatGPT prior to last year's Black Friday. In the United States, Google introduced Universal Cart, which incorporates AI features like price tracking and identification of relevant promotional codes.
However, there has been criticism suggesting that verifying information from AI can sometimes require more effort, while certain brands are actively working to ensure their products appear in chatbot responses.
When testing four different models to locate a 55-inch TV deal using the free versions of popular tools, the experience produced mixed outcomes.
OpenAI's ChatGPT provided four options. Its primary suggestion was a Hisense TV available on the Chinese retailer Joybuy's site for £499, reduced from £649. The second recommendation was a 55-inch TCL TV, though a sidebar displayed prices for the 50-inch version ranging from £379 to £814. Option three was the same Hisense TV, listed at full price of £649 from John Lewis and Richer Sounds. ChatGPT designated this as the "best safer purchase" because the retailers offered longer guarantee periods, but the links provided for both retailers were non-functional, with both stating the TV was no longer listed online. The fourth option was another TCL TV, priced at full cost and £150 above the budget, and it was unavailable online. ChatGPT concluded its suggestions with an "OLED option to compare" for a £1,100 LG TV marked as an "Ad."
Claude delivered the most concise response among the models tested and offered limited detail regarding the specifications of each model. It appeared to base its findings on a small quantity of online reviews and recommended the same two TCL TVs as ChatGPT. When the links were clicked, they directed users to two defunct pages on the Richer Sounds website, and other links pointed to outdated round-ups of Black Friday 2025 deals. Claude expressed reservations about its other two recommendations due to a scarcity of independent reviews, describing one as "a decent option" while stating it "wouldn't pick" the other. It also listed two Samsung TVs but advised against purchasing them, noting one was "over budget and not clearly better than the TCLs."
Gemini presented a pattern similar to other AI models, suggesting different Hisense and TCL models compared to previous chatbots. Gemini generated a comparison table for four distinct models but did not include links to the named stores, requiring users to search for them independently. The price for one TCL TV was accurate at £649, but it was sold out at one of the named retailers. It stated another TCL model was available from Argos and Currys for £539; while this was correct for Argos, the price at Currys was £60 higher. Gemini also included two Samsung models that it advised avoiding because of lower screen specifications.
Alexa presented four TVs, ranging from its own Amazon Ember at £532 to a Samsung priced at £699. Its top suggestion was a different Samsung model at £616 (reduced from £749), based on its picture quality and Amazon customer rating. Its fourth choice was a 50-inch Sony TV, which raised questions about its inclusion. All prices stated by Alexa were correct, but Amazon only searches its own store. Alexa acknowledged this limitation, advising users to check competitors for potentially better deals, noting that prices can vary and longer guarantees might be available elsewhere.
Regarding inconsistent pricing, tech journalist Alex Hughes reported having better success using ChatGPT's agentic AI mode to locate a TV during last year's Black Friday sales than the researchers did. Agentic AI is noted as being in its nascent stages, enabling AI to execute multi-step tasks with greater autonomy. Hughes stated that the search required approximately 20 minutes with minimal input from him, writing for Tom's Guide in November 2025. A year later, he informed the BBC that he did not proceed with buying a TV at that time. He subsequently purchased one of the seven models surfaced by ChatGPT, but he found it at a lower price in a physical store. When asked if he would use AI to find Black Friday deals again this year, he responded that he probably would not, citing the inconsistency and frequent inaccuracy of live price data.
Naureen Mohammed, who advises businesses on how to get their products featured in AI results, observed that customers do not receive a complete picture when interacting with chatbots. She noted that if businesses fail to update prices as bargain hunting begins, "last year's prices are served up as today's deals." Mohammed suggested that the advertising model is likely to begin influencing AI recommendations. Her analysis of UK chatbot Black Friday tech deals indicated that major retailers performed best, with Amazon appearing in half of the responses, followed closely by Currys. Her advice includes asking an assistant if the price is current and clicking on provided links, as users "shouldn't take any advice from the AI system at face value."
Separately, consumer group Which? recently stated that inaccurate pricing within AI results added extra work outside of the process of hunting for Black Friday deals. Senior researcher Hannah Walsh commented that if a user asks ChatGPT for a list of 10 laptops under £400 and seven of the results are priced higher, the user has likely wasted significant time reviewing them only to find the bot offered only three options. She also noted that the reverse is true, as users might overlook excellent models within their budget if ChatGPT incorrectly states they are more expensive than they actually are.