Rescuers Warn Against Relying on Google Maps for Fell Navigation
Rescuers have noted an increase in young people becoming lost or into trouble on fells after using Google Maps for navigation, with experts advising that navigation education is as crucial as technology limitations.
According to the BBC UK, rescue teams have observed that a growing number of young individuals, predominantly aged 18 to 24, have encountered difficulties or become lost while using Google Maps on their mobile phones. Wasdale Mountain Rescue Team (WMRT) stated that Google Maps is unsuitable for mountainous terrain because, unlike a paper map, the application does not depict features such as steep rocky outcrops, fell paths, or contours that illustrate the land's three-dimensional shape.
Rescue teams have consistently recommended the use of a paper map for years, prompting questions about how navigation can be made more accessible to younger generations. Mountaineering and climbing instructor (MCI) Pippa Archer, based in Kendal, acknowledged the appeal of using a free and readily available phone application but noted that a map and compass do not require significant investment. Archer emphasized that the detail provided by a paper map is vital for safety, as it offers a visual representation of what to expect during a walk, which is key to avoiding getting lost. She further explained that a walking map can indicate areas where the ground becomes very steep, cliffs that must be avoided, or streams that require crossing.
Winter mountain leader and MCI James Anstee suggested that the rise in Google Maps usage in mountain settings might reflect evolving navigation habits rather than solely poor judgment or inadequate preparation. Anstee commented that the familiarity and dependability of the app in daily life might lead users to assume it is equally appropriate for the mountains, without fully grasping the demands of the terrain. He asserted that the primary issue is related to awareness and education as much as it is to the technology itself. Anstee suggested that educating people on the limitations of navigation applications, as well as terrain knowledge and suitable navigational competence, would likely be more beneficial than simply discouraging the use of a specific application.
Archer maintained that even with the proliferation of digital devices, a compass and a map remain the safest tools because applications can freeze when there is no signal or may require an update while on the fell without phone reception. This concern was highlighted by an incident where three men required assistance on a Sunday after becoming lost while walking from Scafell Pike using a Google Maps application that had not updated, rescuers reported.
Archer offered navigation advice, stating that she only utilizes a navigation application for two specific functions: to quickly determine her location or to zoom in for a clearer view of the map, and she advises taking map screenshots as a backup. Regarding compass use, she mentioned that the fundamental principle is that the red end of the needle always points north, which enables one to determine east, south, west, or north, and combining this with a map allows for selecting the correct path descending from a summit. For those beginning to learn navigation, Archer advised them to undertake a route they are familiar with while carrying a walking map to practice correlating the surrounding land with the map's representation. She also suggested seeking guidance from a more experienced friend or enrolling in a one-day navigation course when learning to use a compass.
A spokesperson for Google stated that their map application was designed for streets and that it provided estimated arrival times based on standard walking speeds, while also displaying clear warnings that conditions could change. The company encouraged hikers to utilize trail maps and applications specifically developed for hiking.