assembled.
United Kingdom

Two Officers Sacked After Lying About Missing Person Searches in Fatal Crash Case

Two police officers, PC Richard Hardwick and PC Lauren Livingstone, have been dismissed following a police misconduct hearing after they were found guilty of lying about conducting missing person searches related to a 2023 crash that resulted in three deaths.

AI illustration based on reference photographs; not an event photograph. An editorial illustration of a damaged vehicle resting in a dense, empty wooded area under an overcast sky.
AI-generated illustration

According to the BBC UK, two officers were dismissed after a police misconduct hearing found them guilty of lying regarding missing person searches connected to a crash in which three individuals died. PC Richard Hardwick and PC Lauren Livingstone faced allegations of gross misconduct concerning their conduct before a vehicle carrying five people was discovered crashed in a wooded area off the A48 in St Mellons, Cardiff, in 2023.

The hearing, which took place in Newport, determined that both officers were dishonest in official logs and when speaking to a senior officer, by asserting that searches had been performed at the residences of Eve Smith, who died, and Sophie Russon.

PC Richard Hardwick faced six allegations, which included lying about searching the homes of crash victims Smith and Russon, as well as misleading his supervising officer and the police watchdog. PC Lauren Livingstone faced four allegations, which involved lying about searching the two houses, making an inaccurate entry in the log, and lying to her supervising officer.

The four-day police disciplinary hearing at Rodney Parade indicated that both officers were part of the team assigned to investigate reports that Eve Smith, Darcy Ross, and Sophie Russon had gone missing after a night out on Friday, March 3, 2023. The three women were reported missing to Gwent Police on March 4, but were not located until 30 hours after the initial contact by the families. Five people were found in a car in a wooded area off the A48, 46 hours after the vehicle had crashed.

Three of the occupants of the car, Eve Smith, Rafel Jeanne, and Darcy Ross, had passed away, while two, Sophie Russon and Shane Loughlin, sustained serious injuries. Hardwick and Livingstone visited Russon's home and subsequently Smith's house, and as part of Gwent Police's missing person policy, they were required to search the addresses for potential clues regarding the circumstances of their disappearance.

Hardwick documented in the official log that a 'premise search conducted' and informed the police sergeant overseeing the case that the search at Russon's house had been completed. He also stated that searches had occurred when he spoke with the IOPC, which later conducted an investigation. This contradicted what Russon's father, Nathan, told the hearing, who stated the officers were at the house for only a brief time and did not request to search the bedroom.

Livingstone stated she could not recall if searches had taken place, yet she documented what the panel head described as a 'poorly written' report in the official log, which was deemed 'deliberately vague' but implied a search had occurred.

The panel concluded that Hardwick and Livingstone failed to conduct a search at the homes of Smith and Russon. Hardwick was found to have submitted a false entry into the police log and provided dishonest statements when interviewed by the IOPC. He was also found, in part, to have given a dishonest account of the search to his supervisor and in part to have provided a dishonest account in a signed statement to the IOPC. Livingstone was also found to have provided a false entry into the police log and to have given a dishonest account of the search to her supervisor.

Panel chairman Ian Arundale stated that the officers' conduct caused harm due to its effect on the family and undermined public confidence in the police in a case that generated significant public concern. He noted that a final written warning was not an option because the degree of culpability and the level of harm were too high, and there were no mitigating factors. Arundale added that Hardwick and Livingstone deliberately misled a missing persons investigation, which potentially compromised the investigation and eroded public trust in the police in a high-profile case.

Derrick Campbell, representing the Independent Office for Police Conduct (IOPC), stated that the officers failed to 'act honestly and with integrity,' emphasizing that property searches are a 'basic but essential part in the early stages of a missing person investigation.' Campbell noted that PC Hardwick deliberately lied during the missing person investigation by claiming on police records and to his supervisor that searches were finished. Furthermore, Campbell stated that PC Livingstone had the opportunity to inform the IOPC that the necessary searches had not been conducted, but instead, she offered no account and claimed she could not remember the specifics of her visits to the homes of the two young women reported missing.